Intellectual Property: A Two Sided Coin for Franchisors and Entrepreneurs

If you are a successful franchisor or entrepreneur (of a non-franchised business), chances are that you place great priority on the development of your "intellectual property" such as your trademarks, trade designs and innovations that may be the subject of a patent. While successful business owners and entrepreneurs are great at innovating and creating "intellectual property", sometimes, mistakes are unnecessarily made respecting the protection of your "intellectual property.

When evaluating the development and protection of your intellectual property, the following are some factors that you should be aware of and considering as you manage your critical intellectual property assets:

Intellectual property is a "Two-Sided Coin" and is not limited to just "One Thing".  That is, your view toward your intellectual property assets should be expansive and involve the recognition that you are not just limited to "trademarks" or "patents".  Many of the key intellectual property assets that comprise your business may be afforded an array of protections involving trademarks, patents and a  broad array of "common law" protections associated with "trade secrets", "customer lists", "production sources" and other confidential components that drive your business.  The key is to properly structure your legal approach to these assets and afford them the maximum protection possible.  For example:

- Have your key employees with access to confidential information about customers and production sources signed limited but enforceable confidentiality agreements;

- Do you review with your corporate counsel the current usage of your trademarks to ensure that your trademark registrations are current and that supplemental applications are not warranted;

- Have your production sources signed off on confidentiality agreements respecting key components or processes involved in the production of your proprietary products and supplies; 

-Have you evaluated key product designs to determine whether or not your product may benefit from a "design patent.

As you are certainly aware there are many more issues and considerations concerning the protection of your intellectual property assets.  However, the basic and extremely limited point I wish to convey that the creativity that you put into developing the unique intangible assets that drive your business should also be applied toward the active management and protection of these assets.  Set a plan and actively discuss the protection of these critical assets with your corporate counsel. 

 

The "Franchisor's Mindset": Some Factors that Franchisors and Franchisees should Consider

For both (a) franchisees deciding on the right franchise investment and (b) franchisors establishing a solid franchise system, the right "mindset" is critical.  That is, it is critical that your understanding of franchise opportunities and franchise systems go beyond the generalized and  involve a  detailed understanding and evaluation of the overall mindset that a successful franchisor brings to the table. Reflecting on "some" of the critical points that my clients have raised over the years, the following is my take on some of the factors that you (whether a prospective franchisee or franchisor) should be considering in evaluating a "franchisor's mindset":

  • Focus on Franchisee Training is Paramount - Smart franchisors, that is franchisors that are focused on the "long-term" are focused franchisee training.  That is, the long-term road to franchise growth and the development of a valuable franchise system must be premised on the consistent development and training of its franchisees and not just a quick sale of a franchise unit.  Is the franchisor focused on evaluating franchisee qualifications and and developing systems for for both initial and on-going training?  
  • Franchise Growth Must be Planned and Controlled - Somewhat related toward a franchisor's "training mindset" is the franchisors "mindset toward growth".  Franchise systems that grow to "fast" (i.e., at a rate that is not readily supported by expanded training, system development and market evaluation) are bound to fail.  Is the franchisor focused on controlled growth and growth that takes place only after developing the necessary support and brand development systems?
  • Product Development must be Ongoing - One of the primary advantages of becoming a franchisee (in the right franchise system) is leveraging off of the franchisors centralized efforts in constantly developing, refining and improving the products and services that its franchisees offer.  Product and brand development is a constant and on-going process and is critical to the continuing success of a franchise system. Is the franchisor focused on systems and a  process that continuously reinforces and refines its brand and the products and services offered to its customers.

There are many, many more points and steps that successful franchisors follow.  However, key to every franchise is a franchisor and franchise management team that approaches each day with a "mindset" focused on controlled growth, franchisee development and product development.

Franchisors: How do you Reduce your "Litigation Exposure" and "Legal Fees"?

Short Answer:  Avoid lawsuits.  That is, work on and establish with your legal counsel "legal systems and procedures" that is designed to avoid unnecessary litigation. (Slightly longer answer follows)

While the advice that I am offering here may sound obvious and, possibly, even a little self-serving, it is nevertheless an honest and critical point that far too many franchisors and business owners overlook.  That is, in most (but not all) litigation once your are involved (either as a plaintiff or defendant) the advantages and benefits that may or may not stem from the outcome of the litigation will, many times, be outweighed by:

(a) the legal fees that you will incur,

(b) lost productivity associated with your focus on the lawsuit (as opposed to building your franchise systems), and

(c) the uncertainty that is inherent in all litigation - no matter how strong your case is.  

Faced with the inherent costs in all litigation, the best course of action for both start-up and established franchisors is to establish with your legal counsel open channels of communication focused on cutting-down and mitigating your "litigation exposure".  That is, in addition to the critically important task of managing your regulatory requirements and disclosures as a franchisor, you must discuss and establish with your legal counsel a fair and flexible relationship and system focused on the management and monitoring of your day-to-day legal activities. Some of these activities should include:

(a) The review of vendor agreements,

(b) The establishment of standardized franchisee communications and compliance notices;

(c) The quarterly evaluation and review of your trademarks and the filing of supplemental trademark applications and affidavits;

(d) The establishment and maintenance of a specified and well documented "encroachment policy" respecting the grant of additional franchises;

(e) The establishment of a clear and concise policy respecting the negotiated modification of your franchise agreements;

(f) The maintenance of strategic employment agreements with your key employees that are focused on the implementation "enforceable" restrictive covenants;

While establishing an on-going day-to-day working relationship with your legal counsel may be more expensive than "doing nothing", the value of this planning process will far outweigh the cost associated with unnecessary and avoidable litigation. Once tasks become standardized and well establish, my experience has been than many activities may be incorporated into the tasks of your "in-house" staff and, over time, serve to reduce your long-term legal fees.

 

Franchisee Profitability: 8 Days, 8 Months or 8 Years

This afternoon in consulting with a client who had recently signed a franchise agreement involving a substantial commitment of capital, I was reminded about the importance of maintaining "realistic" expectations when buying a franchise. When discussing his expectations about his franchise purchase and the business that he will be developing, he was extremely "realistic" as to his expectations and the work ahead of him.  That is: 

(a) He diligently evaluated the "franchise opportunity" that he was investing in and thoroughly understood that, as with many businesses, it would be a number of months and possibly years (hopefully not) before he achieved a level of profitability and acceptable return on his franchise investment; and

(b) He understood that the success of his franchise rested on the hard work, marketing and business development that he (and his family) would bring to this new business. Significantly, his approach is not one of "lets wait and see" what business comes through the door.

The most important lesson that I was reminded of by my client - a lesson that future franchisees and franchisors may also put to use - is that getting your expectations "right" is critical.  When considering a business opportunity and setting your "expectations", franchisors and franchisees should consider:

  • Profitability will Take Some Time -   Profitability is not guaranteed and, depending on your particular franchise opportunity, may take 8 days (unlikely), 8 months or 8 years (hopefully not).  That is, you must plan ahead and account for the extremely realistic fact that you in selling a franchise or purchasing a franchise you must properly communicate and/or understand that reserve capital will be critical.  Evaluate the opportunity thoroughly and ensure that you have developed the correct expectation about the future profitability of your business.
  • Franchisors Can't (and Shouldn't) do Everything - Buying a franchise does not mean you just pay money and then sit back and wait for business to "walk through the doors".  You must be actively engaged in the marketing and "development" of your business.  Look to your franchisor as your "partner" and not your "caretaker".  Franchisors, be selective about the franchisees that you approve - look for franchisees that will contribute to the development of your franchise system. 

Get your expectations right.

New York Seminar: How to Buy Your First Franchise

NYC Business Solutions (a division of NYC Small Business Services), the Manhattan Chamber of Commerce and the US Department of Commerce will be conducting and coordinating a seminar - "How to Buy Your First Franchise or Grow the One you Have" -  for both prospective and current franchisees.  

Seminar Date:  February 17, 2010

Seminar Time:  8:00 AM - 10:00 AM

Seminar Location:  110 William Street, 4th Floor, New York, NY 10038

Seminar Registration Information

 If you are considering the purchase of a franchise your best resource and asset will be "information". Information about the franchisor, information about your legal rights, information about your estimated start-up expenses and information about your rights and obligations as a franchisee.  My point being attending a seminar such as the one offered by NYC Business Solutions can only be helpful in this important decision making process.

Hopefully, you will also find our articles about  buying a franchise to be helpful. Good luck.

Franchisor Basics: Disclosure of Financial Statements

Part of the “Franchisor Basics” Series

Under the Federal Franchise Rule franchisors are required to disclose their “Financial Statements” in Item 21 of the Franchise Disclosure Document. All financial statements must be prepared in accordance with Generally Accepted Accounting Principals ("GAAP") and in all but an extremely limited number of situations involving a start-up franchisor, a franchisor’s financial statements must be “audited”.   In the franchise regulations (16 CFR Parts 436 and 437) FTC provides detailed information respecting a franchisor's "Item 21" disclosure requirements, including:

  •  Financial statements must be audited by an independent certified public accountant and prepared in accordance with GAAP;
  • Financial statements must be prepared in a "tabular" format providing for a comparison between current and prior fiscal years; and 
  • Financial statements must include (a) Balance Sheet for the prior two (2) fiscal years and (b) Statement of Operations, Stockholders Equity and Cash Flows for each of the franchisor's prior three (3) fiscal years. 

Other provisions apply for "start-up" franchisors (a topic that will be discussed in future posts) and the disclosure of the financial statements of a franchisor's "affiliates". 

Franchising Basics

In an effort to expand the information provided at the New York Franchise Law Blog and, hopefully, the timeliness and value of this information for our readers and subscribers, we will now be featuring a continuing series of succinct fact based articles (in addition to our commentary and reports) focused on the "basics of franchising", comprised of "Franchisor Basics" and "Franchisee Basics".

These articles will serve as a valuable reference tool to our readers and, as always,  it is important that you discuss the specifics of your franchise system, disclosure obligations and franchise decisions with your franchise attorney.

As always, we appreciate and welcome the comments and suggestions that we have been fortunate to receive from our readers. Please let us know if there are any specific franchise topics that you like us to address.  Thanks.

Buying an Existing Franchise: Is their Value in the "Franchise System"?

When  purchasing an "existing business" (whether a franchised or independent operation) prospective purchasers are faced with the critically important task of conducting a "due diligence" evaluation/investigation of the business under consideration.  While there are many steps to the "due diligence" process and while many of these steps are the same whether the business is a "franchised operation" or an "independent location", one critically important distinction and factor that should not be overlooked and must be evaluated by the prospective purchaser of an existing franchise is:

"whether or not there is value in the franchise system?".

That is, as a purchaser, you must evaluate and determine what added value (i.e., profits and cash flow), if any, that you will be afforded by purchasing and operating a "franchised business" (and becoming a franchisee) as compared to a competing but "non-franchised" independent operation. When making this "assessment" you must recognize that there is tremendous variation and value between franchises - that is, some franchise systems add real value and advantages while some poorly run "franchise systems" simply drain the profitability of its franchisees.  When making this assessment, some of the factors that you should consider, include:

  • Higher Sales Do Not Necessarily Equate to Higher Profits.  As a franchisee one substantial obligation that you will be undertaking will include the payment of "royalties" to the franchisor.  Since royalties are typically based on a percentage of your "gross sales" the franchised business that you are evaluating will most likely have higher operating costs than the non-franchised business.
  • Not all Franchise Systems are Equal.  Some "franchise systems" are simply poorly run and ill conceived business operations that afford little, if any, value to its franchisees.   So, don't just "assume" that the franchise business that you are considering will be properly supported by the franchisor - ask questions, speak to other franchisees and evaluate the benefits of the franchise system that you are buying into.

Start-Up franchisors: What is the Right Franchise Fee and Royalty Structure for Your System?

For the "start-up franchisor" (and even established franchisors) determining the appropriate franchise fee and royalty structure for your franchise system is a critical task that will have long standing implications.  The fee structure that you establish will serve as the primary source of revenue for your franchise system and will represent one of the most significant "expenses and obligations" on the part of your franchisees.  Set the fees to high and you risk franchisee and, ultimately, franchise system failure.  Set the fees too low and you risk "franchise system" failure resulting from your inability (as the franchisor) to properly support, develop and expand your system. 

The process of establishing your franchise fee and royalty structure should not be based on a rigid formula or a formula that simply duplicates the fees charged by your "perceived" competitors. Rather, your franchise fee and royalty structure should reflect the unique characteristics of your business, the sophistication of your existing business systems, the strength of your trademarks and your future obligations to maintain, develop and refine your franchise system and the rights of your franchisees.

When establishing these fees, some of the critical factors/principals that you should be considering, include: 

  • The Initial Franchise Fee Should Reflect the Value of Your Existing System(s). In many respects the initial upfront franchise fee that you will charge to your franchisees should reflect the value of the existing "system(s)" that you have already established.  Higher franchise fees are usually predicated on valuable, well established and tested "systems" and intellectual property assets.  In making this assessment, consider:

(a)  The legal strength of your trademarks and their USPTO registration status;

(b)  The strength and recognition of your trademarks and trade dress by consumers in the marketplace;

(c)  The competitive advantage(s) that will be afforded to your franchisees by your "established" business systems, products and services, including unique products and sources of supply.

  •  The Initial Franchise Fee Should Reflect Your Initial Training Obligations. The initial training of your franchisees will play a significant factor in the development of your franchise system and the success of your franchisees.   Your initial franchise fee should reflect and give consideration to the initial training obligations that you will be undertaking as you add each franchisee.  Your franchise fee must be sufficient to ensure that you possess the necessary financial resources and systems to properly train your franchisees.
  • Your Royalty Structure Should Reflect Your Business and be Geared toward Franchisee Success. The relationship between franchisor and franchisee is one of interdependence.  That is, to be a truly successful franchisor, you need successful franchisees.  When structuring the ongoing royalty obligations of your franchisees, consider:

(a)  Successful franchise systems require successful franchisees, so ensure that the ongoing royalty rate reflects the economics of your individual franchise units and does not inhibit franchisee "profitability";

(b)  Royalties must be sufficient to support and pay the expenses associated with your current and ongoing efforts and obligations to continuously refine, develop, recreate and protect the core components of your franchise system.  As a franchisor you will possess some serious and necessary obligations respecting the continued development and refinement of your franchise system.  this is a serious obligation and your royalty structure must be sufficient to properly fund these activities;

(c) Your royalty structure should reflect your business.  Although the typical or predominant royalty structure is based on a fixed percentage of gross sales, start-up (and even current) franchisors should consider possible alternatives that may  better reflect the "unit economics" of their franchisees.

Starting a Franchise: How should You Approach the Development of Your Disclosure Documents

For the successful business owner considering the franchised expansion of his or her business one critical question that must be answered is "how do you approach the preparation and development of your franchise agreement."  That is, do you "approach" the preparation and development of your franchise agreement (and franchise disclosure documents) as:

(a) A "legal obstacle" that requires the preparation of "generic" agreements and disclosure documents;

OR

(b) A collaborative process focused on the development of a critical "asset" that uniquely reflects, identifies and protects the components of your business (that is what has made your business successful),  franchise, and  franchise system.  

Why do I ask?  Because your approach will determine the ultimate outcome of this important process.  

Approach "(a)" - the "legal obstacle approach" will typically lead to generic  agreements and disclosure documents that, by all accounts, result in little (if any) value to a developing franchise system.  While this approach may satisfy (or appear to satisfy) your regulatory disclosure requirements they do nothing to advance the development of your "franchise system".  That is, approach "(a)" typically leads to "form over substance" and not much else.  When speaking with start-up franchisors that have followed this approach - an approach that they followed with the best of intentions but based on what may be poor advice - I am typically advised that their franchise agreements simply do not work for their business and franchise system.   

For the start-up franchisor, approach "(b)" is the only true option.  By following this approach your franchise agreement and disclosure documents will serve as core business "assets: that will reflect and protect  the unique and critical components of your business and your newly established franchise system.  

When starting a franchise keep in mind that all agreements are not the same and and that your input will be critical to insuring that your agreements and disclosure documensts reflect the unique nature of your business.  This is no easy task and is not one that is not simply delegated - an indepth working relationship with your franchise lawyer is required.